As a die-hard Soulsborne fan, I was absolutely buzzing when Elden Ring Nightreign was announced! This isn't just another DLC—it's a whole new beast. FromSoftware is finally giving us a dedicated co-op roguelike experience with a dash of battle royale spice, and I'm here for it. The map shrinks, the stakes are high, and we get to team up with two other Tarnished to conquer it all. But you know what would make this already epic adventure even more legendary? Bringing back some of the most iconic, game-changing weapons from FromSoft's incredible history. The trailer already teased the return of some classic bosses, so why not their signature armaments too? Let's dive into my ultimate wishlist for weapons that deserve a glorious comeback in Nightreign.
✨ 1. The Legendary Moonlight Greatsword ✨
This is non-negotiable, folks! The Moonlight Greatsword isn't just a weapon; it's a hallowed tradition, a piece of FromSoftware's soul. Since the very first King's Field back in the day, this majestic, magic-imbued blade has been a constant, beloved companion. 
-
Why It Belongs in Nightreign: Nightreign is a standalone spinoff—the perfect canvas to paint a fresh, new interpretation of this iconic armament. Imagine a version tuned for intense, fast-paced co-op battles. Maybe its signature beam attacks could have area-of-effect properties to help your squad, or perhaps landing charged attacks could provide temporary buffs to your allies. The potential for team synergy is huge!
-
The Fantasy: Wading into a horde of Nightreign's horrors with this luminous blade, its ethereal glow cutting through the gloom, would be a moment of pure gaming magic.
🗡️ 2. Rivers of Blood Katana 🗡️
Yes, I said it. The most infamous, the most maligned, the most beautifully broken katana from the base game. We all remember the chaos it caused in PvP back in 2022. While it's been toned down since then, Nightreign presents a golden opportunity.
-
Why It Belongs in Nightreign: Nightreign is focused on PvE! This is the chance to let Rivers of Blood shine in its full, unapologetic glory against the game's monstrous enemies, not other players. Let that Corpse Piler skill unleash torrents of crimson once more!
-
The Fantasy: Coordinating with your team to stun-lock a towering boss with successive, searing slashes that paint the battlefield red. Pure, unadulterated style and carnage.
🔧 3. Bloodborne's Saw Cleaver (The OG Trick Weapon) 🔧
Bloodborne's arsenal is arguably the pinnacle of FromSoft weapon design. The Trick Weapon system—transforming your tool mid-combo—is a stroke of genius, and the Saw Cleaver is its poster child. It's simple, brutally efficient, and dripping with Yharnam's gritty aesthetic.
-
Why It Belongs in Nightreign: Introducing Trick Weapons to the Elden Ring universe would be a game-changer for Nightreign's combat flow. The Saw Cleaver's quick, serrated slashes transforming into heavy, sweeping strikes would add a dynamic layer to managing the ever-shrinking arena and swarming enemies.
-
The Fantasy: The satisfying click-clack of transforming the weapon to adapt on the fly, seamlessly switching between clearing mobs and focusing down a priority target with your squad. A love letter to 2015.
🔥 4. Dark Souls 3's Ringed Knight Paired Greatswords 🔥
If you want to talk about sheer, unbridled style, look no further. Dual-wielding these colossal, flaming slabs of metal in Dark Souls 3 was an experience. While Elden Ring has spiritual successors like Starscourge Greatswords, they often require NG+ to dual-wield.
-
Why It Belongs in Nightreign: Nightreign's roguelike structure means every run is fresh. Finding or unlocking these bad boys in a run would be an instant "build-around" moment. Their moveset is all about aggressive, sweeping flurries—perfect for a mode where space is limited and crowd control is king.
-
The Fantasy: Being the anchor of your three-player team, a whirlwind of fire creating space and drawing aggro while your allies cast spells or snipe from a distance. Pure, cinematic power fantasy.
⚡ 5. The Dragonslayer Spear (Ornstein's Legacy) ⚡
Elegance and power personified. This spear, wielded by the legendary Dragonslayer Ornstein, is a piece of Dark Souls history. It's not just a poking stick; it's a conduit for lethal lightning, combining reach with elemental devastation.
-
Why It Belongs in Nightreign: The spear's long reach and lightning attacks would offer a fantastic tactical option. In a tight, shrinking map, controlling space is crucial. A powerful, charging lightning bolt skill could pierce through multiple enemies or interrupt dangerous boss attacks, providing crucial support for your team.
-
The Fantasy: Honoring one of FromSoft's most iconic knights by channeling his power, striking from the safety of distance with bolts of ancient lightning. A classic, refined weapon for a chaotic new mode.
👑 BONUS DREAM PICK: Demon's Souls' Northern Regalia 👑
Let's take it back to the very root of the Soulslike genre. The Northern Regalia from Demon's Souls is the ultimate reward for a monumental effort, forged from two legendary swords. Its power scaled uniquely with your character's tendency, making it deeply personal.
-
Why It Belongs in Nightreign: Nightreign could implement a similar, run-specific scaling mechanic. Perhaps its damage fluctuates based on your team's collective performance or the challenges you've overcome in that particular attempt. It would be the ultimate high-risk, high-reward treasure, perfectly suited for a roguelike's meta-progression.
-
The Fantasy: After a flawless run with your squad, finally crafting this symbol of royal power and using it to claim victory. The ultimate flex.
What do you think, fellow Tarnished (and Hunters, and Ashen Ones)? Which classic FromSoft weapon are you desperately hoping to see make a comeback in Elden Ring Nightreign? The potential for blending this incredible legacy with a brand-new, co-op focused format has me more excited than ever for 2026! Let me know your top picks in the comments! 👇