Okay, fellow Tarnished, Hunters, and Ashen Ones, gather 'round the bonfire. As we look back from 2026, it's wild to think about the journey we've been on with FromSoftware's DLCs. They're not just extra content; they're these seismic events that reshape entire games, sometimes even outshining the main adventure itself. I've spent countless hours (and deaths) in these expansions, and today I'm laying out my definitive, personal ranking. Grab your Estus, sharpen your Saw Cleaver, and let's dive in. 🗡️🔥

🥉 8. Ashes of Ariandel - A Flawed Snow Globe

  • The Vibe: A beautiful but lonely painted world that feels a bit... empty.

  • The High: Sister Friede & Father Ariandel. This boss fight is a three-act masterpiece of pain and beauty, a true contender for the best in Dark Souls 3.

  • The Low: Everything else. The level design is flat, the enemies are repetitive, and the story feels like a tantalizing prologue that never got its full sequel. It's like finding a single, perfect snowflake in an otherwise barren field.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-0

🥉 7. Crown of the Sunken King - An Underwater Temple of Ideas

  • The Vibe: Exploring the ruins of Shulva feels like spelunking in a forgotten, poison-drenched Atlantis.

  • The High: The vertical, puzzle-box level design. You're constantly activating pillars, riding elevators, and discovering secrets. It was a blueprint for the legacy dungeons we'd later love in Elden Ring.

  • The Low: The infamous optional co-op area and its gank squad boss. We don't talk about that. 😭 This DLC is a treasure trove of brilliant ideas that, sadly, felt a bit like a first draft for greater things to come.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-1

🥈 6. Crown of the Ivory King - A Breathtaking, Frustrating Blizzard

  • The Vibe: A majestic, frozen kingdom being consumed by chaos. The spectacle of the Burnt Ivory King boss fight entrance is still unmatched.

  • The High: Burnt Ivory King himself, and the tragic, beautiful lore of Alsanna and Eleum Loyce.

  • The Low: Frigid Outskirts. This co-op area is a special kind of hell with invisible reindeer in a blinding snowstorm. It's the peak of FromSoftware's "unforgiving" design, for better and definitely for worse.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-2

🥈 5. Crown of the Old Iron King - The Pinnacle of Dark Souls 2

  • The Vibe: Ascending the ash-choked, industrial nightmare of Brume Tower. It's oppressive, tense, and brilliant.

  • The High: The boss roster. Fume Knight and Sir Alonne are legendary fights that demand perfection. Walking the giant chains in the tower is a set-piece moment that lives in my head rent-free.

  • The Low: Yet another annoying, reskinned co-op area boss (Blue Smelter Demon, I'm looking at you). But the highs here are so astronomically high, they eclipse the lows.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-3

🏆 4. Artorias of the Abyss - The Timeless Classic

  • The Vibe: Stepping back in time to witness a legendary tragedy. It feels ancient, mournful, and profoundly important.

  • The High: The lore and the bosses. Meeting Artorias, the fallen hero, is a gaming moment for the ages. The entire boss lineup (Artorias, Manus, Kalameet) is S-tier.

  • The Low: The boss runbacks. Oh, the runbacks. They are a relic of a (thankfully) bygone era. But even with that, this DLC hasn't aged a day. It's like a vintage vinyl record—the scratches are part of its authentic, timeless charm.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-4

🏆 3. The Ringed City - The Perfect Finale

  • The Vibe: The end of the world. A somber, beautiful, and utterly apocalyptic journey to the literal end of the Dark Souls timeline.

  • The High: The sense of finality and the god-tier bosses. Slave Knight Gael is the greatest final boss in gaming history, a poetic and brutal end to the trilogy. Darkeater Midir is a dragon fight perfected.

  • The Low: Halflight, Spear of the Church (a PvP-focused boss that can be a mood-killer). But this DLC is a masterclass in sticking the landing. It's the epic, tear-jerking final chapter of a beloved book series.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-5

🥈 2. Shadow of the Erdtree - A Universe in a Bottle

  • The Vibe: 2026 and I'm still discovering secrets in the Realm of Shadow. It's a mind-bogglingly dense, beautiful, and cruel new world.

  • The High: The sheer scale and quality. It's a full-blow sequel packed into a DLC. The new weapon types, the insane legacy dungeons, and bosses that make Malenia look tame. It redefined what an expansion could be.

  • The Low: The initial difficulty spike had the whole community in shambles (RIP). But conquering it was a collective triumph. This DLC is a cosmic event, a black hole of content that sucks you in and refuses to let go. It's the only DLC ever nominated for Game of the Year for a reason.

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-6

🥇 1. The Old Hunters - The Inseparable Heart

  • The Vibe: A descent into the mad, bloody nightmare where it all began. It's horrific, tragic, and somehow even more stylish than the base game.

  • The High: It completes Bloodborne. The base game feels incomplete without it. Ludwig's transformation, Lady Maria's duel, the Fishing Hamlet—it provides essential context and delivers the game's best bosses and areas.

  • The Low: There are none. Seriously. It is flawless.

While Shadow of the Erdtree is a monumental achievement, The Old Hunters isn't just an expansion; it's the missing piece of the puzzle. Bloodborne and The Old Hunters are a symbiotic pair, like a hunter and their trick weapon—separate entities that only reveal their true, devastating potential when combined. For that perfect, inseparable union, it will always be my number one. 🩸🌙

my-personal-ranking-every-fromsoftware-soulsborne-dlc-from-good-to-goat-level-image-7

So, what's your ranking? Do you agree, or is your love for the Realm of Shadow or The Ringed City too strong? Let me know in the comments—let's get this debate going! 👇💬