Yo, fellow Tarnished! So, back in 2024, every single one of us who braved the Lands Between probably daydreamed about hoisting one of those massive, lore-drenched swords in real life. Fast forward to 2026, and let me tell you, that dream isn't just a fantasy anymore—it's sitting right here in my gaming den. I finally got my hands on Panda Studio's replicas of the legendary Dark Moon Greatsword and Maliketh's Black Blade, and holy moly, the detail is something else.

my-elden-ring-sword-collection-dark-moon-greatsword-black-blade-replicas-review-image-0

Unboxing the Legends: First Impressions

When these bad boys arrived, it was like Christmas for a FromSoftware fanatic. Let's break down what you get:

  • Dark Moon Greatsword: This beauty is currently in stock (as of 2026) and measures a whopping 150cm in length. It's made from high-quality resin and comes with a sleek backplate, so you can mount it on your wall and stare at it for hours—no judgment here. The price tag? A cool $583. Yeah, it's an investment, but for the centerpiece of any collection, it's worth it.

  • Maliketh's Black Blade: This one had a pre-order period. It's slightly shorter at 147cm and was priced at a more accessible $160. It also ships with a display backplate. Holding it, you can almost hear Gurranq's growls... spooky.

Both are marketed as 1:1 replicas, which sparked quite the debate in the community (more on that later). But just holding them, you feel the weight of the Erdtree's history. It's wild.

The Great Size Debate & Jaw-Dropping Details

Alright, let's address the elephant—or should I say, the Red Wolf of Radagon—in the room. Some fans were quick to point out a... slight discrepancy. In the game, Maliketh's Black Blade feels like it's closer to 200cm tall, literally towering over your Tarnished. The replica, at 147cm, does feel a bit more... manageable. This led to some folks calling out Panda Studio about that "1:1 ratio" claim.

But here's the kicker, and it's a point other players brilliantly made: the sword's size in-game totally changes depending on who's wielding it! On Maliketh? It's a building. On our Tarnished? Still huge, but maybe not quite as absurd. So, calling it "inaccurate" isn't entirely fair. It's more like a "Tarnished-scale" version, which honestly makes more sense for display in a normal human room!

Where Panda Studio absolutely nailed it, though, is in the texture and markings. The community has always geeked out over the insane weapon details you can see in the ghostly previews, and these replicas capture that magic.

  • The Dark Moon Greatsword has this ethereal, cold moonlight effect etched into the blade. It's not just painted on; it has a depth to it that catches the light perfectly. It's the kind of detail that makes you whisper, "Whoa..."

  • The Black Blade's ominous, rune-like carvings and that distinct jagged shape are recreated with painful accuracy. You can practically feel the Destined Death emanating from it (okay, maybe not, but you get the vibe).

From Game to Shelf: The Lore Behind the Blades

Owining these isn't just about having cool decor; it's about holding a piece of the story. Let me nerd out for a sec:

Weapon How to Get It In-Game (2026 Edition Knowledge!) What Makes It Special
Dark Moon Greatsword Complete Ranni's quest, give her the ring, find it below the Cathedral of Manus Celes. A FromSoftware staple! Scales with Int, has that iconic moonlight wave skill. The crown jewel for any sorcery knight build.
Maliketh's Black Blade Defeat the beast clergyman himself, Maliketh, in Crumbling Farum Azula. A Colossal Sword that deals holy damage and inflicts HP drain. Looks and feels like it could slice a god in half—because it basically did.

Remember the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC that dropped back in June 2024? It added so much punishing lore and bosses that these weapons feel even more significant now. They're not just tools; they're trophies from a journey.

Final Verdict: Are They Worth It?

So, after living with these on my wall for a while, here's my take:

For the casual fan? The Black Blade is a fantastic, more affordable entry point. It's iconic, detailed, and just imposing enough.

For the completionist, the lore addict, the Ranni simp (guilty as charged)? The Dark Moon Greatsword is a must-have. It's the definitive Elden Ring trophy. The price is steep, but the craftsmanship justifies it for a true centerpiece.

The size thing? Honestly, once you have it in your hands and on display, it stops mattering. What matters is the feeling—that connection to the hundreds of hours you spent in that beautiful, miserable world. Panda Studio captured the soul of these weapons, and that's what counts.

It's been a couple years since these first dropped, and in 2026, they still feel just as magical. They're a permanent monument to the game that defined a generation for us. Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go stare at my Greatsword and contemplate the cosmos... or maybe just my next build. \ (^_^) /